When I tell most people that I have a reel mower they look at me as to say — “What? Mine is not real?” — then I spell it out, “it is a r-e-e-l mower”; you have got to love homonyms. Afterwards folks usually understand, then I get a plethora of questions about the whys and hows. The answers to those questions are a bit more involved…
The main reason I went with a reel mower is because power mowers are REALLY bad for the environment. According to the EPA the average gas-powered lawn mower emits as much pollution per hour as 11 automobiles do during the same time span. Lawn mower engines are known as two-cycle engines; the average two-cycle engine emits over 90 times more pollution per gallon of fuel than any car or truck. For me, using a power mower negates most of the effort I put out by riding my bicycle instead of driving a car.
There are other reasons I decided to use a reel mower: no gasoline, less noise, smaller when stored, easier to maintain. They also have the added benefit of allowing me to mow my yard while the kids are outside. Power mowers throw things all over the place, and do not stop as easily as a reel mower. With a reel mower it stops making noise when I stop pushing it, and I do not have to yank on it to start mowing again. That makes it easier for me to watch the kids and still get the yard mowed.
One of the questions I always get is “how well does it cut”? The answer is, good enough. Power mowers create a suction vortex under the deck that pulls grass and weeds up a bit, then cuts everything. A reel mower pulls the grass in with the spindle, then presses it against a cutter bar. Since there is no suction, the reel mower does not cut everything. However, since there is no blade swinging around when the mower is at rest, it is easy and safe to bend over and pull a missed weed out of the ground by hand. The reel mower does an excellent job of cutting thick healthy grass. What it usually misses are tall weeds and wild grasses; however, it will still get most of those. See for yourself, the picture on the left is of my yard right after I cut it with a reel mower.
I will say that the reel mower is harder to push than a power mower. It also takes a bit longer to cut my grass with as well. My front lawn is about an eighth of an acre and it takes about 45 minutes to cut with a reel mower. The reel mower also does not get as close to the edge of walkways and flower beds as a power mower. Of course, it also does not blow debris into my flower beds like a power mower does.
Another advantage of a reel mower is the cost. I bought mine from the local hardware store for $135. It has a 20 inch cutting width, has several height settings, and came with a bag to catch clippings. A comparable power more cost more than $200. The cost of ownership of a reel more is also next to nothing. With a power mower there are added expenses such as gas, oil, and spark plugs.
If you have a small to medium yard that is primarily covered with grass, and do not mind a bit of work, a reel mower is a great option. Otherwise, I would suggest looking into something different. As for me, I am sticking with the old fashion, no pollution option.